Friday, May 5, 2017

My response to Jeff Immelt on linked in

https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/competing-world-jeff-immelt?trk=eml-email_feed_ecosystem_digest_01-hero-0-null&midToken=AQHLMTwDqN2T0A&fromEmail=fromEmail&ut=1DDtfzRBcJYnI1#pulse-comments-comment-urn:li:comment:(article:7235290773767289305,6266264237815926784)



What has really happened is that we have destroyed a generation of children by putting too much pressure on them in elementary school, especially early elementary school, forgetting children learn by play, and eliminating arts education. Arts education teaches children creative thinking. Our kids were always the most competitive because they could think. 

In the idiotic search for college prep, we have eliminated Home Ec and Shop from middle school and high school. We're raising a generation of kids who can't do anything, who only know how to take tests, who are helpless in the real world. 

My dad taught graduate physics at the University of Wisconsin. He always found that the best students were kids raised on farms, because they knew how to do things. 

We've become obsessed with the test results of foreign students, not seeing  that those students were neurotic droids. We decided to make our kids neurotic droids as well. 

Test results have nothing to do with what will make our kids internationally competitive. We have destroyed the world's best education system in the misguided attempt to imitate foreigners. 


Now that we have destroyed our youth we are doomed on the international market. Sorry. It's too late. 

2 comments:

  1. My kids had shop classes, home ec, and music, but they still had a hard time motivating themselves to do anything. I think it was a combination of an overly protective environment and the ascendance of the computer/gadget as primary companion in kids lives.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes. We do teach little kids that outside is dangerous.

      We so emphasized that people on the Internet could be dangerous that now my children, now adults, won't ever meet f2f with someone they met on the Internet.

      I used to walk to school alone, even at 5 years old, now people are arrested for having their kids walk to school alone.

      And, yes, the computer is addictive.

      Delete